 |
| Being friends does not mean we share one personality, one reputation, or joint custody of each other’s mistakes. |
They say birds of a feather flock together.
Okay—but have you ever met two friends who agree on everything?
Because unless those birds share one brain and pass it around on a schedule, being friends does not make people identical.
Still, that saying has been embedded in my mind for years because my father once used it against me. He did not know my friends personally. He did not spend time with them or know how they behaved. But apparently, somebody had seen a group of girls hanging around with boys and flirting.
Somebody decided that group was us.
It wasn’t.
Did that matter?
Of course not. Why allow facts to ruin a perfectly good accusation?
Guilty by Friendship
My parents were very strict when I was growing up. They did not like me going out, so when I finally made friends with a group of girls, getting permission to spend time with them was already difficult.
Then somebody told my father that my friends and I had been seen hanging out with boys and flirting.
My father became furious.
I tried to explain that it was a different group. The girls people had seen were older than us. We were freshmen, and those girls were juniors. We had seen them ourselves, so we knew exactly who they were.
But my father had already heard the story, accepted the story, and apparently closed the investigation.
Case dismissed.
Except I was still guilty.
He would not listen to me because, in his mind, the situation proved the old saying:
Birds of a feather flock together.
The problem was that they had identified the wrong damn birds.
Our Group Had a Ridiculous Rule
Here is the funniest part: my group had a rule that nobody was allowed to have a boyfriend.
Yes, seriously.
A group of freshmen created a no-boyfriend policy as if we were managing a convent instead of trying to survive school.
It was a stupid rule, obviously. Who were we to control whether somebody got a boyfriend? But it proves how far the accusation was from reality.
People were claiming that we were out flirting with boys while our group was busy enforcing its own unnecessary relationship ban.
We were not experienced troublemakers.
We were children with bylaws.
But once an adult believes something about you, especially a strict parent, explaining yourself can feel completely useless. Every defense sounds like an excuse. Every detail becomes suspicious. The more you try to prove your innocence, the more they wonder why you are trying so hard.
Maybe I was friends with those girls, but I was still my own person. Even if one of them had flirted with a boy—which apparently was treated like an international crime—I would not automatically be responsible for it.
Friendship is not a group conviction.
Friends Can Be Completely Different
I have never understood why people assume friends must share the same behavior, beliefs, personality, and mistakes.
Have you met actual friends?
One friend wakes up early. The other considers noon a reasonable breakfast time.
One saves money. The other sees a sale and suddenly develops financial amnesia.
One wants to discuss feelings. The other would rather fake their own death.
One is outgoing. The other is already looking for the exit.
People become friends for all kinds of reasons. They may share a sense of humor, understand each other’s struggles, or simply enjoy spending time together. That does not mean they approve of every decision the other person makes.
I can like someone without copying her.
I can disagree with someone without ending the friendship.
I can sit beside somebody without absorbing her entire personality through physical proximity.
That is not how friendship works.
Then There Was the Beautiful Girl Everyone Hated
I remember another girl who was beautiful—and people despised her.
They said terrible things about her. One person even called her filthy.
But from what I personally saw, she was not filthy at all. She had become a target because somebody was jealous of her, and once the gossip started, other people joined in.
That is how rumors work. One person says something with enough confidence, and suddenly everyone behaves as if they personally conducted an investigation.
I became friends with her because I preferred judging her based on how she treated me—not on the miserable little reviews people kept submitting.
Then one of my friends warned me that if I hung out with someone “like her,” people would assume I was the same.
Excuse me?
The same as what?
Beautiful and unfairly judged?
Terrifying.
Sometimes the Warning Is Just Another Form of Control
People often disguise judgment as concern.
“I’m only telling you because people might talk.”
“I’m just worried about your reputation.”
“You know what they say about her.”
Yes, I know what they say.
I also know people say a lot of stupid shit.
Sometimes they are not protecting you. They are pressuring you to participate in the same rejection. They want you to distance yourself from someone because that person has already been marked as unpopular, strange, difficult, or unacceptable.
If you refuse, they make your reputation part of the threat.
If you stand beside her, we will judge you too.
That is not advice. That is social blackmail.
And honestly, it says more about them than it does about the person they are attacking.
Judge Me for What I Do
If I lie, judge me for lying.
If I treat people badly, judge me for that.
If I behave like an asshole, then fine—bring the evidence and open the case.
But do not convict me because somebody I know did something you dislike.
I am not responsible for every choice my friends make. They are not responsible for every stupid thing I do either.
And thank goodness for that, because my friends already have their own problems.
They do not need joint custody of mine.
There is a difference between noticing a dangerous pattern and making lazy assumptions. If every person in a group bullies people, lies constantly, or participates in harmful behavior, then yes, it makes sense to question why someone willingly stays involved.
But merely being friends with someone does not prove you share every flaw they have—especially when the accusations are based on gossip in the first place.
Context matters.
Facts matter.
Individual behavior matters.
Apparently, that requires more effort than repeating a proverb and walking away.
You Can Care About Someone Without Becoming Them
A real friendship leaves room for differences.
You can have different opinions, priorities, backgrounds, and personalities. You can tell a friend when she is wrong without deciding she is permanently worthless. You can recognize her flaws while still recognizing the good in her.
Friendship should not require matching identities.
It should not mean blindly defending everything someone does, either. If my friend behaves badly, I can acknowledge it. I can tell her the truth. I can even step away if her behavior becomes harmful.
But I will make that decision based on what I witness—not because a bored person handed me a rumor and expected immediate obedience.
I have been judged unfairly before, including in situations where people barely gave me a chance. It reminds me of what happened to my son when a company hired him and then dismissed him on his first day for supposedly lacking experience. I wrote about that in If You Wanted Experience, Why Did You Hire Him?.
Different situation, same lazy habit: people make a quick judgment, refuse to look deeper, and then act as though their first assumption must be correct.
The B.S. Truth
“Birds of a feather flock together” can sometimes describe why people connect.
It should not be used as proof that everyone in a group is exactly alike.
My friends are not extensions of me. I am not an extension of them. We are separate people who happen to enjoy each other’s company.
Some of my friends have made decisions I would never make.
I have probably made decisions that caused them to ask what the hell was wrong with me.
That is normal.
If you want to know what kind of person I am, watch what I do. Pay attention to how I treat people. Talk to me before accepting somebody else’s version of my life.
And if you see me standing beside a woman everyone else has decided to hate, do not assume I am just like her.
Maybe I simply took the revolutionary step of getting to know her first.
B.S. or Truth?
Have you ever been judged because of the people you were friends with? Did anyone assume you were guilty of something just because somebody in your group supposedly did it?
And have you ever discovered that the person everyone warned you about was nothing like the rumors?
Tell me in the comments. Let us see how many people have been convicted under the highly scientific law of “Well, you know who she hangs out with.”
No comments:
Post a Comment